Most EU companies use AWS, Azure, or GCP. American cloud, American company, American jurisdiction. But does that mean your data is in America? Not necessarily. Here's how data sovereignty works when you're using US cloud providers — and what architecture controls actually keep your data under EU law.
Data sovereignty means your data is governed by the laws of the country where it resides. EU personal data is governed by GDPR. If that data sits on a server in Frankfurt, GDPR applies. If it sits on a server in Virginia, US law applies — and GDPR's protection may not.
The concern isn't theoretical. Schrems II (2020) invalidated the Privacy Shield, which was the legal basis for transferring EU personal data to the US. The EU-US Data Privacy Framework replaced it in 2023, but gaps remain. US cloud providers are subject to US legal processes (CLOUD Act, FISA warrants) that can access data held by US companies regardless of where it's stored.
AWS, Azure, and GCP all offer EU regions (Frankfurt, Paris, Amsterdam, Dublin, Stockholm). Storing data in an EU region means it physically resides in the EU. That's necessary. But it's not sufficient.
Here's why: a US cloud provider operating an EU data centre is still a US company. US legal processes can compel a US company to produce data, even if that data is in an EU data centre. The EU region gives you physical residency. It doesn't give you legal sovereignty.
EU residency is where the data lives. Sovereignty is who can reach it. A server in Frankfurt operated by a US company is in Germany — but the company that controls it is in the US.
You can't eliminate all risk when using US cloud providers. You can reduce it significantly with the right architecture:
US cloud providers offer the best infrastructure, the most services, and the widest region coverage. EU alternatives (OVHcloud, Hetzner, Scaleway) are improving but don't match the breadth. Most EU companies will use US cloud — and that's a legitimate choice if the sovereignty controls are in place.
The mistake isn't using American cloud. The mistake is using American cloud without sovereignty architecture — no EU regions, provider-managed keys, no data classification, backups replicating to US regions. That's where data goes from "in the EU" to "reachable by US legal process."
Under NIS2 and GDPR, regulators want evidence that you know where your data is and who can reach it. "We use AWS" is not evidence. "We use AWS EU regions only, encrypt with customer-managed keys held outside AWS, classify personal data and segregate it, and monitor for cross-border replication" is evidence.
The architecture controls are the difference between "we use cloud" and "we use cloud sovereignty."
Aethel Guard is a Netherlands-based security architecture firm serving EU companies of all sizes. Your architect, not your vendor.