If you use AWS, Azure, or GCP, your data is held by a US company. The CLOUD Act (Clarifying Lawful Overseas Use of Data) lets US law enforcement compel US companies to produce data — even if that data is stored in an EU data centre. Here's what that means and what you can do about it.
Passed in 2018, the CLOUD Act allows US courts to issue warrants for data held by US-based technology companies, regardless of where the data is physically stored. If your cloud provider is headquartered in the US, they're subject to CLOUD Act warrants.
This means: a US warrant can reach data in an AWS Frankfurt data centre. The server is in Germany. The company that controls it is in the US. The CLOUD Act says the company must produce the data, even from Germany.
GDPR says EU personal data can only leave the EU with adequate protections. The CLOUD Act says US law enforcement can access data held by US companies anywhere. When both apply, you're caught between two legal systems.
Schrems II (2020) recognised this tension and invalidated the Privacy Shield. The EU-US Data Privacy Framework (2023) replaced it, but the underlying conflict remains: US legal process can reach EU data through US companies.
You can't refuse a CLOUD Act warrant by saying "the data is in the EU." The provider is US-based. They must comply. Your contract with them may say "we'll protect your data" but US law overrides contract terms.
You can't eliminate CLOUD Act risk on US cloud providers. You can reduce it to acceptable levels with the right architecture. The question isn't "should we use US cloud" — most EU companies will. The question is "do we know which data is exposed, and have we architectured to minimise it?"
If the answer is "we use AWS and encrypt everything" but AWS manages the keys, the encryption doesn't help under CLOUD Act. If the answer is "we classify data, use EU regions, hold our own keys, and keep PII off US infrastructure where possible" — that's sovereignty architecture.
Aethel Guard is a Netherlands-based security architecture firm serving EU companies of all sizes. Your architect, not your vendor.